Page 3 of 4

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Thu 14. May 2020 17:28:42
by Mikej
Ok - a small update here.

I upgraded to 2.8 firmware a couple of days ago and today was the first proper flight with that. Whilst the integration and Spirit based sensor info is OK, I'm not getting the HobbyWing info through anymore.

I had a crash that promptedd the change to 2.8 (I was waiting for parts) - so I'll check my wiring see if that got damaged

Edit - err quick update on HobbyWing integration - after a long detailed, forensic investigation it appears that the problem was simple - some idiot had plugged the integration cable back into the wrong socket n :roll: :roll: :roll: :lol: :lol:

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Thu 14. May 2020 20:28:08
by denis747
Mikej wrote:Ok - a small update here.

I upgraded to 2.8 firmware a couple of days ago and today was the first proper flight with that. Whilst the integration and Spirit based sensor info is OK, I'm not getting the HobbyWing info through anymore.

I had a crash that promptedd the change to 2.8 (I was waiting for parts) - so I'll check my wiring see if that got damaged

Edit - err quick update on HobbyWing integration - after a long detailed, forensic investigation it appears that the problem was simple - some idiot had plugged the integration cable back into the wrong socket n :roll: :roll: :roll: [emoji38] [emoji38]
[emoji23] Good catch!

I forgot to mention that my Spirit firmware is version 2.8 and all the Hobbywing sensors work.

Sent from my SM-G950F using Tapatalk

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Thu 14. May 2020 21:00:20
by xoexoe
Here is what happens during my sensor lost issue.


https://youtu.be/Hvs_m4wkqBc

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Thu 14. May 2020 22:48:08
by Mikej
The only obvious difference is that Dennis I are using the "small but perfectly formed" QX7, whereas you and Dan are using the Horus / Horus clone, perhaps it is something to do with the different LUA????

But just to confuse things Adrian seems to be using both Horus and QX7 - do you get the same problem with the QX7 Adrian?

FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Sat 16. May 2020 20:01:33
by xoexoe
I set up my new Spirit 2 FBL on my Oxy 4 Max. It also has the same issue using my same Horus. But what’s interesting is that after losing telemetry I went into my telemetry menu on OpenTX to see what was going on. Of course my Hobbywing info is not communicating, but I still have data from my FrSky LiPo cell checker! This FrSky sensor goes directly to the S.Port and doesn’t get filtered into the FBL unit like the Hobbywing telemetry does.

(My other heli above, the micro Spirit on Oxy 2, did not have a LiPo cell checker installed.)

Item 7 below is the LiPo sensor. Item 8 is a calculated value based on item 7.

Image


Now I’m tempted to try that Arduino-Hobbywing-S.Port project that some on HeliFreak are using.

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Sun 17. May 2020 12:01:33
by ZeXx86
Hello,

when you enter the Spirit integration menu Telemetry sensors are not updated to make the integration faster. But immediately after closing the menu it should work again.
This is normal and correct behavior.

In case telemetry sensors would update all the time, integration menu speed would be slower.

FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Sun 17. May 2020 18:33:58
by xoexoe
The telemetry doesn’t work even after closing integration. If it started working again after closing then I don’t think it’d bother me too much.

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Sun 17. May 2020 20:18:54
by p.i.engineer
have you tried resetting telemetry to see if it works.

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Sun 17. May 2020 21:17:22
by xoexoe
Yes, I reset telemetry using the OpenTX menu, then tried rediscovering sensors. No reconnection.

Re: FrSky OpenTX integration "Sensor Lost"

Posted: Tue 19. May 2020 11:15:02
by ZeXx86
Hello,

it look like OpenTX developers decided to remove EXIT command from Lua support in Horus.
I dont know what was the reason but this is why sensors are not updated anymore even after exiting the scripts.

Very likely Status LED is still blinking after exiting - which should not happen.

Downgrading to older OpenTX should resolve the problem. We have to update Lua scripts in some way to make it work probably.